I ordered the ribeye steak for $35 and, unfortunately, it was unusually tough and chewy. I sawed fruitlessly with my oversized serrated steak knife trying to cut through the sinew, knocking the vegetables off my plate. I was unable to eat about one-third of the steak and ended up leaving a large portion on the plate. At this price, I think it's reasonable to expect a quality steak. I informed our waitress, who said she would tell the chef, but she did not offer to do anything when she returned. Judging from two or three reviews by other customers, I am guessing that Oyster Bay may not always purchase the best cuts of meat. I would not recommend ordering a steak here.
The best restaurant in Cape May, hands down! Nice small, personal setting, owner is a master chef from the Culinary Institute, food is plated in a very appetizing way....and tastes absolutely delicious! Very friendly waitstaff and hostess. The Fried Tomato and Crabmeat appetizer is to die for, and I had the Scallops and Shrimp Nage which I can't find words to describe...except delicious! Do yourself a favor and go here instead of the moldy smelling Lobster House, which is just a tourist trap. You'll be glad you did!!!!
Extremely overpriced, staff wasn't overly friendly and the food was just plain tasteless. Took the wife, 11 year old son and 5 year old son. I got the rack of lamb, it was horrible. Wife got the scallops and they looked like the came from Redlobster. Calamari was horrible, their marinara that you have to ask for the calamari was horrible. I got my son plain pasta with butter and Parmesan and he wouldn't even eat it. I got the oysters and they were actually good so I'm giving a star for that. The waitress could tell we where very unhappy but still remained pleasant and 3/4 of the meals were not eaten and we still got stuck with a $175 bill. The funny thing is the place was packed. . Not impressed.....
We have been coming here for years and keeps getting better everytime. We love the seasonal menu. Never had a bad meal. Staff is always friendly and attentive. We highly recommend Oyster Bay. We live 2.5 hours away but make the drive just to have dinner and go back home. Yes. It is THAT good.
Nice interior good food nice staff
Oyster Bay Restaurant Bar is a US Bar based in Cape May, New Jersey. Oyster Bay Restaurant Bar is located at 615 Lafayette St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA.
Please contact with Oyster Bay Restaurant Bar using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Oyster Bay Restaurant Bar opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Bar in Cape May