My wife and I celebrated our first anniversary at Hemingway's last weekend. The staff treated us like royalty, they were incredible. The food and atmosphere were exceptional as well. Special thanks to Gary and Siobhan who went out of their way all evening! We will be back.
Based only on event food we had here. Can't say anything about ordering from the menu. IT was very very good!! Sooo good. The steak was melt in your mouth, the sides are soooo rich and delicious. Can't wait to come back. The staff was super nice!!!
Food was just ok- service was terrible due to lack of education about customer service procedures. Staff was obviously not taught by management or by the chef, proper procedures for problems that occur. We dined at the Restaurant on Thursday, August 10th. Ordered soup (which was acceptable) and salads. Server brought our salad order and gave it to another family in the restaurant. She then, about a minute or 2 later, must have realized her mistake, retrieved the food and, with a smile, brought it and sat it down for us to eat- as if she had just come from the kitchen. When I asked her if the others had touched our food, she realized that we knew the error and then said she could take it back. We declined- as we believed that you will have worse luck with returned food. Good customer service would have been to acknowledge the error, take the food back into kitchen and provide new salads.
Nice atmosphere. Table service was ok. Had to request bread that should gave been on the table. They were attentive, but not the friendliest. I ordered the broiled seafood combo. It was totally covered in butter. The shrimp was slightly overcooked, and the crab cake was average at best. Scallops and fish were ok, but I couldn't get around the butter. The baked potato was not good. It tasted like it was reheated from last night. My wife's salad was good. Desert was a let down, but not bad. For a restaurant that serves $30 entrees (which is average for Cape May) I would look elsewhere.
"The Anniversary Couple"
Everyone from the hostess, to the bus boy were very attentive. My family and I found it to be competetively priced, good portions, plenty of flavor. The bartenders pour old school, and drinks were very fairly priced. Also had breakfast at the buffet. Same great service and delicous food!
Hemingway S Steaks Seafood Restaurant is a US Night Club based in Cape May, New Jersey. Hemingway S Steaks Seafood Restaurant is located at 1045 Beach Avenue, in the Grand Hotel, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA.
Please contact with Hemingway S Steaks Seafood Restaurant using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Hemingway S Steaks Seafood Restaurant opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.